Front wheel rubbing the fiber after recall?

Hey guys, I had a headlight recall done and didn't notice immediately, but I think they might have messed up the fiber barrier that goes in the right side wheel well just behind the bumper. I only noticed it because I'm definitely getting tire rub when at lock, which didn't happen before I don't think. Stock tires btw.

Is this something I can quickly fix? I tried pressing it back in with no success. Should I press harder?

Pics for ref